Catalonia has no right to be independent.

Catalonia because neither can nor should be independent.

Internet has given us the ability to be interconnected, write what we think, and also express our ideas around any topic especially if we compete and in which we are linked. And the issue of Catalonia is one of them, is fundamental and essential part of Spain that is made up all Spaniards from first to last, such a complex and heterogeneous fan, anyone can you, we can remove this absolute power to decide for part or in whole, in the national territory, so we turn to history.

Nor Catalan Kingdom,nor Catalan Country.These terms, today hackneyed and generalized by the independence, dramatically collide with reality and history. It has materialized only illegal proclamation of the Catalan state three times to the present. All, from the nineteenth century and after the birth of nationalist fervor. However, in each and sanity government they acted to root out those separatists who -in 1873, 1931 and 1934 attempted to carry out an illegality.

And, even if hurts a lot, history does not lie. Catalonia, contrary to what we led to believe, already part of the Roman Hispania and visigoda.And he never had consideration of State. In fact, he became one of the domains of the Crown Aragon after the rey Ramiro II married his daughter Petronila with Ramón Berenguer IV (Count of Barcelona) in 1151.was, ultimately, a way to acquire, via marriage, those territories craved.

Based on this union was born the Crown of Aragon.Not the Crown of Catalonia. And therefore current terms as"Catalan Countries","Catalano-Aragonese Confederation"or"Crown Catalonia Aragon"(today more popular thanks to independentismo) have little reality.

An attempt to state

the term Catalan state remained forgotten until the arrival of the First Republic.A form of government that arrived at the Spanish borders as culmination of the revolutionary process of 1868 and after the sign that marked the reign of Amadeo I of Savoy (who just sat their real two years on the throne).

"Nobody brings; they bring all circumstances ", he said of the new regime Emilio Castelar,Minister of State since the proclamation of the First Republic in 1873.

The experiment would expensive in the end. In the few 22 months spread over time the power went through four presidents no less. To make matters worse, from June 11, 1873 the Parliament enacted the establishment of a federalist system (despite not getting to be implemented in principle) favored the confrontation between different regions.

Already he said the jurist Juan Ferrando Badía in his"First Spanish Republic":"Federalism was a great utopia [...] that shaped the mentality of [...] regionalism".

ldefonsosuarez.es/

example was the birth -a 1873- up from 26 cantonal movements seeking independence of small regions like Camuñas or Motril.The struggle for autonomy came to absurdity in regions like Jumilla (today, a town of about 970 square kilometers). Not surprisingly, since that territory was sent the following: "The jumillano nation wishes live in peace with all the neighboring nations and, above all, Murcia nation, its neighbor; but if the murciana nation dares to ignore their autonomy and beyond their borders, Jumilla will defend itself. "

In this context occurred (between 5 and 7 March 1873) the proclamation of the Catalan state by the Malaga Born anarchist José García Viñas and French socialist doctor Paul Brousse."The drivers were representatives of Catalan and Balearic councils gathered at the Palace of the Generalitat" says the Catalan historian Andreu Navarra Ordoño in his book"The Suspicious region. The hispano catalana dialectic between 1875 and 1939".

The expert adds that the direction of movement fell on Baldomero Lostau,the"federalist Catalan left."Implying that little action was that of independence and, on the contrary, it really looked the coup was pressure the government Estanislao to implement Figueras,once for all, federal promises it promised.

so clear in the title that gave the putschists to his new political experiment"Catalan State federated with the Spanish Republic"(ABC).